MEXICO: ARBITRARY DETENTION OF VÍCTOR HUGO AGUILAR OLIVER
The International League Against Arbitrary Detention urges the Government of Mexico to take all the necessary actions to implement the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention Opinion No. 70/2022 concerning Víctor Hugo Aguilar Oliver, asking the Government of Mexico to immediately and unconditionally release Víctor Hugo Aguilar Oliver and to accord him an enforceable right to compensation and other reparations in accordance with international law.
Read the full WGAD Opinion concerning Víctor Hugo Aguilar Oliver (Mexico): Opinion No. 70/2022.
MEXICAN NATIONAL ARBITRARILY ARRESTED BY UNIDENTIFIED INDIVIDUALS
Mr. Aguilar Oliver is a national of the United Mexican States, born on 11 August 1977. He was 35 years old at the time of his arrest.
On 5 August 2013, Mr. Aguilar Oliver was violently arrested in the city of Tuxtla Gutiérrez, State of Chiapas, by unidentified individuals. No arrest warrant was produced, and no reasons for the arrest were disclosed.
After his arrest, Mr. Aguilar Oliver was held in an undisclosed location for four hours, then taken before a prosecutor of the Ministerio Público Fiscal. During those four hours, Mr. Aguilar Oliver was subjected to torture aimed at extracting a confession regarding his alleged participation in the kidnapping and femicide of two women. He was reportedly told that the women in his family would also be tortured unless he signed the confession.
On 9 August 2013, Mr. Aguilar Oliver was taken to the Centro Estatal de Reinserción Social para Sentenciados No. 14 under Mexico’s mandatory pre-trial detention regime and was held there for more than 3,000 days without a definitive resolution to his legal situation.
In its 2023 Annual Report to the United Nations Human Rights Council, the Working Group reported having received information from the source that Mr. Aguilar Oliver had been released on 24 October 2022.
The Government of Mexico responded to the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention transmission, denying allegations of arbitrary detention.
ARRESTED WITHOUT A WARRANT AND TORTURE TO EXTRACT CONFESSION.
The source alleged that Mr. Aguilar Oliver was arrested on 5 August 2013, without a warrant and by unidentified persons. A search and location order was later found in the applicant’s file, with the date of the arrest altered to 6 August 2013. The Mexican Government, in its response, failed to provide evidence establishing the exact date of the arrest, as it did not rebut those statements and denied the production of the search and location warrant.. The Working Group therefore considered that the Source provided credible evidence that Mr. Aguilar Oliver was arrested without a warrant and without being told the reasons for his arrest, in violation of article 9 (2) of the Covenant.
Additionally, the source stated that Mr. Aguilar Oliver was denied the right to be promptly brought before a judge, given that he was taken to an undisclosed location and only subsequently brought before a prosecutor. The Working Group also recalled that the Public Prosecutor’s office cannot be considered an independent judicial authority and therefore cannot review the legality of detention. As a result, the Working Group concluded that the arrest violated, inter alia, Articles 3 and 9 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 9 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
The source declared that Mr. Aguilar Oliver remained in detention under Mexico’s mandatory pre-trial detention regime for more than 3,000 days without a definitive resolution to his situation. Non-custodial alternatives were not considered, and the Mexican Government did not contest the nature of the detention. The Working Group considered this pre-trial detention excessive and, because it was not deemed reasonable and necessary through an individualised assessment of the case, equivalent to a substitute for the actual punishment. The Working Group recalled its previous jurisprudence finding Mexico’s mandatory pre-trial detention regime contrary to the country’s international human rights obligations, particularly Articles 9 and 14 of the Covenant, and called on the Mexican Government to bring its domestic law in line with those obligations.
The source also claimed that Mr. Aguilar Oliver was held in incommunicado detention for four hours following his arrest, during which he was subjected to torture aimed at extracting a confession. While the Mexican Government denied the allegations, it recognised that Mr. Aguilar Oliver showed symptoms compatible with torture during his trial. The Working Group recalled that incommunicado detention deprives individuals of contact with the outside world, heightens the risk of torture, and violates the right to challenge the legality of the detention under Article 9 (4) of the Covenant, as well as the right to recognition everywhere as a person before the law under Article 6 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 16 of the Covenant. The Working Group concluded that there was credible evidence that the absolute prohibition of torture, enshrined in article 9 (4) of the Covenant and the Convention against Torture, had been violated in Mr. Aguilar Oliver’s case, as well as his right to an effective remedy, enshrined in Article 8 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 2 (3) of the Covenant.
In light of the foregoing, the Working Group concluded that Mr. Aguilar Oliver’s arrest and detention lacked a legal basis, rendering his deprivation of liberty arbitrary under Category I. The Working Group also referred the case to the Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers and the Special Rapporteur on Torture.
SUBJECTED TO INCOMMUNICADO DETENTION, TORTURE, AND DENIED DUE PROCESS
The source stated that Mr. Aguilar Oliver was not provided with information regarding the nature of the crime he was alleged to have committed and was held incommunicado. Building on these findings, the Working Group considered that the failure to inform Mr. Aguilar Oliver of the alleged offences constituted a violation of the right to be informed promptly of the nature and cause of the charges against him, as well as the right to an effective remedy to challenge the legality of his detention and to seek protection against potential violations of his right to liberty as recognised in Article 8 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 2(3) and 14(3)(a) of the Covenant.
Furthermore, the source provided evidence that Mr. Aguilar Oliver was subjected to torture to extract a confession, and had been held for more than 3,000 days in pre-trial detention without an individualised determination of the circumstances of the case and without a periodic review. Although the Mexican Government claimed that the accusation against Mr. Aguilar Oliver was based on the testimony of another witness, the Working Group noted that, because a prima facie case of torture had been established, the burden of proof shifted to the State to demonstrate that the testimony was obtained without coercion. The Working Group explained that the admission of confessions obtained through torture renders the entirety of the proceedings arbitrary, constituting a severe violation of due process due to the length of the pretrial detention. Moreover, it considered that the torture of Mr. Aguilar Oliver undermined his ability to mount an effective defence vis-à-vis the State, violating his right to equality of arms protected by Article 14 of the Covenant.
Therefore, considering the above, the Working Group concluded that the Mexican authorities severely violated Mr. Aguilar Oliver’s rights to a fair, independent, and impartial trial, thereby rendering his deprivation of liberty arbitrary under Category III.
CONCLUSIONS OF THE UN WORKING GROUP AGAINST ARBITRARY DETENTION
In light of the foregoing, the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention considered that the detention of Víctor Hugo Aguilar Oliver was arbitrary and fell under Categories I and III because the deprivation of liberty of Víctor Hugo Aguilar Oliver was in contravention of Articles 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Articles 2, 7, 9, 10, 14 and 26 of the Covenant.
The Working Group recommended that the Government of Mexico take the steps necessary to remedy the situation of Víctor Hugo Aguilar Oliver without delay and bring it into conformity with the relevant international norms. The Working Group considered that, taking into account all circumstances of the case, the appropriate remedy would be to accord him an enforceable right to compensation and other reparations, in accordance with international law.



Comments